Minor TBI and SCI
Major TBI and SCI
Sources of Compensation


Have your case
Reviewed by our
attorneys

 
Legal Aspects

Legal Aspects of the Traumatic Brain
and Spine Injury Case

Traumatic Brain Injury or TBI or Spinal cord Injury (SCI) refers to injury to the brain or spinal cord as the result of a specific external insult to the body as distinguished from a variety of diseases that may cause brain or spinal cord injury. TBI or SCI can occur from a minor automobile impact or from the use of a prescribed medication. The range of causes of trauma to the brain or spinal cord are as varied as the people affected by the trauma.

The legal issues associated with a Traumatic Brain Injury or Spinal Cord Injury are quite similar and require expertise in this area of personal injury law. Like all personal injury cases, TBI and SCI cases have three fundamental elements which must be proved to obtain a successful recovery. First, the injured party must prove that someone is either partly or entirely legally responsible for the harm. Second, the injured party must prove the full nature and extent of the harm. Finally, the injured party must prove the legal damages suffered as a result of the injuries.

Minor TBI and SCI

In cases involving moderate to major TBI or SCI the burden of proof may be easier to meet. In most cases the cause of the trauma is obvious and major. For example a TBI or SCI suffered from a severe impact associated with an automobile accident, or a fall from a significant height, or a deliberate blow to the head can be proven with less effort than a minor TBI or SCI from a low impact collision or minor bump on the head.

Most traumatic brain injuries, about 80% of the annual 2,000,000 TBIs, are referred to as Aminor brain injuries. The word Aminor should never be confused with the idea that the injury to the brain is insignificant. On the contrary, it is often the case that symptoms associated with Aminor TBI are very disabling and can severely affect a person's ability to carry on normal life activities.

From a legal aspect, while a Aminor TBI can be very disabling, it is a medical condition that is more difficult to prove. Unlike a moderate to severe TBI, which is more obvious and easy to prove, the minor TBI involves microscopic damage to the cell structures of the brain. These injuries are not revealed by a physical examination or special radiographic studies such as Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) or Computer enhanced Tomography (CT) that are able to show large lesions and injuries to the brain. case.

Proof of a minor TBI requires special understanding of the symptoms that follow the trauma, the delay that often occurs in noticing differences in a victim's behavior, and special testing by qualified Neuropsychologists and Vocational Rehabilitation Experts.

The lawyer confronted with a case that involves a Aminor TBI must have a keen awareness of the mechanism of the injury, that is, how the accident could physically cause a brain injury. The lawyer must understand what evidence must be obtained to support the medical case for a minor TBI. Finally, the lawyer must be prepared to prove the damages that a person with a minor TBI will suffer. For example, what medical treatment will the client require and for how long. What work restrictions will the person likely encounter and how will the client's future capacity to earn be affected? Will this client be eligible for government assistance of any kind? How will this injury affect the injured victim's ability to obtain or keep medical insurance? These are only some of the questions that a lawyer handling a Aminor or major TBI case must be able to deal with.

These same issues are involved in cases of trauma to the spinal cord. Minor SCI injuries are especially difficult to prove and are quickly dismissed by insurance companies as fraudulent or exaggerated. Minor SCI cases are often referred to as Awhiplash cases. The term Awhiplash was derived from the movement of a persons head that typically occurs with a sudden acceleration of the body such as the effect of a rear end collision to a passenger in a vehicle. Here the head is whipped back and then forward stretching the muscles and bone structures supporting the spinal cord under the base of the skull, referred to as the cervical spine. In most cases of involving Awhiplash of the head and neck associated with a minor forces, such as a Afender bender the injury involves the Asoft tissue structures (muscles, ligaments, tendons) of the cervical spine. Initially, there may be swelling and spasm of these structures. However, an x-ray or other testing will not reveal the damage to these soft tissue structures such as tears to the muscles, or insult to the spinal cord and nerves that emanate from it.

Insurance companies are quick to deny these injury claims because of an unfortunate conviction that people who make these claims are out to make money and are not really hurt. A lawyer handling a minor SCI must be familiar with the mechanics of such injuries and have a relationship with qualified medical experts who can explain how the accident caused the SCI.

While many personal injury lawyers will tackle minor TBI and SCI cases, even if they are not that familiar with the management of a minor TBI or SCI case, no lawyer should attempt to handle catastrophic TBI or SCI cases without first acquiring the necessary expertise.

 
Major TBI and SCI

Management of a moderate to severe TBI and SCI case requires a lawyer to have a keen understanding of how to present the case. The critical role of the lawyer is to assemble a dynamic and highly qualified team of expert witnesses. The facts of every personal injury case are unique to that case. The type of expert witness necessary, if any, to assist in proving the responsibility or "liability" for the accident will vary. The lawyer must be aware of how to locate such experts such as Safety Engineers, Biomechanical Engineers, Human Factors experts, Accident Reconstructionists, and others that deal with the particulars of the event that caused the injury.

Proving the nature and extent of the harm and the damages suffered is very complex when addressing a catastrophic TBI or SCI. The lead experts with respect to the medical issues will usually consist of a Neurologist, who specializes in brain and nervous system disorders, and the Physiatrist who is Board Certified in Physical and Rehabilitation medicine. The Neurologist will address the nature and extent of the brain or spinal cord damage. The Physiatrist will assess the medical needs and rehabilitation potential of the whole person. The Neurologist or Physiatrist will usually head up a team of care providers. This may include an Occupational Therapist who will assess and deal with rehabilitating the individual to be able to deal with daily living needs and a Physical Therapist who will focus on achieving maximum physical recovery. Other experts may include Speech Therapists and Massage Therapists.

A Neuropyschologist is important to evaluate the level of brain injury and function. A Psychologist is necessary to address the psychological trauma associated with the severe brain and spinal cord injury. These injuries are life altering and have severe emotional implications. The Psychologist can assess the extent of the emotional harm and address the level of care, and costs associated with future, often lifetime, treatment.

One of the most important experts that the lawyer must include on the legal management team is the Life Care Manager or Life Care Planner. This expert is critical to assessing the amount of future medical care damages that are necessary to recover in order to provide the best quality of life possible under the circumstances of the injury. The Life Care Planner, usually a Rehabilitation Nurse with experience as a Nurse Case Manager, will, with the input of the Neurologist or Physiatrist and other medical specialists, determine what lifetime care the patient will require. This includes home and work adaptive needs; attendant care; bowel-bladder care; hygiene needs; mobility needs such as lifts, wheelchair, van or other transport; medical and physical therapy needs; and other associated care requirements over the remainder of the injured victim's life. The Life Care Planner will obtain all of the medical costs associated with the life care needs and will assemble this information into a comprehensive Life Care Plan.

Once the Life Care Planner identifies all of the future medical care needs and costs, this information, the Life Care Plan must be provided to an expert Economist. The Economist will then determine the present value of these future medical care needs. In other words, this Economist will calculate how much the injured victim will need in a lump sum amount of money to be paid now, that can be conservatively invested such that the interest and principal will cover all of the anticipated future medical needs identified by the Life Care Planner.

The lawyer must also enlist the services of a Vocational Rehabilitation Expert. This Expert will perform an assessment of the loss of earning potential due to the injuries. This Expert will identify what the injured victim could have earned before the accident given his or her pre-injury education, skill and experience. The Vocational Expert will perform various work related tests to determine what level of earning capacity the person has, if any, post injury. Once this is determined, the expert will perform a labor market survey and calculate what this person will now be able to earn, if anything following maximum recovery. Once this assessment is done, the evaluation is given to the Economist who then performs calculations to determine how much money the person should be compensated now as a lump some that can be securely invested to recreate an income stream equal to what they would have earned had they not been injured. As an example, if a person was making $10.00 per hour and now can only earn $5.00 per hour he or she will need enough money so that they can invest that money and earn the missing $5.00 an hour for the rest of their work life.

 
Sources of Compensation

There may be numerous sources from which the TBI or SCI victim may have a right of recovery depending upon the circumstances giving rise to the cause of the injury. The following is an effort to provide the reader with some generic information which would have to be pursued by an attorney experienced with the handling of TBI and SCI cases.

WORKER COMPENSATION BENEFITS

Temporary Disability

Many TBI or SCI cases arise out of a person's employment and are caused by an activity associated with their employment. Under such a circumstance, the injured employee will likely be entitled to certain worker compensation benefits. While the specific entitlements may differ from state to state, there are certain basic benefits that are common to most worker compensation systems. The injured employee is entitled to receive a Temporary Disability (TD) benefit that is usually based upon a percentage of their average weekly wage at the time of the injury. This TD benefit is paid while the employee is undergoing medical treatment and has not reached a point in their medical care where their condition has been determined by the medical providers to be permanent and stationary.

Medical Care

The injured victim is entitled to have his or her medical treatment associated with the injury paid for by the employer or the employer's worker compensation insurer for the rest of his or her life. The employer or the employer's worker compensation insurance carrier will often attempt to "control" these costs by insisting that the injured employee obtain treatment from physicians and facilities preferred by the insurance company. In most states the employee has the right, at some point in their treatment, to choose their own health care provider. The employer or its insurance company must still pay for the employee's choice of health care providers.

Permanent Disability Benefits

Once the injured employee reaches a point in his or her medical treatment where the physician(s) agree that no further medical treatment will improve the level of the patient's disability, the injured employee is eligible to receive a Permanent Disability Benefit (PD). The amount of this benefit is usually determined by the percentage of disability and other factors such as the person's age, type of work, and education. These PD benefits are calculated as a weekly amount of benefit and are paid every two weeks. There are ways to negotiate a lump sum payment in lieu of the weekly benefit, which is usually accomplished through a settlement with the employer or worker compensation insurance company.

Vocational Rehabilitation

Most worker compensation systems require the employer or its insurance company to provide the injured employee with vocational retraining if they are not able to return to their usual and customary work. There may be a limit on the amount of cost that the employer or insurance company will be required to pay for this benefit.

Every state is different and the injured party should consult with a lawyer familiar with the worker compensation benefits in his or her state. For the serious TBI or SCI victim the benefits offered through worker compensation may be very substantial, especially as a means of funding a life time medical care plan.

STRUCTURED SETTLEMENT OF A PERSONAL INJURY CASE

If the TBI or SCI victim was injured as the result of the fault of another and the other party has adequate insurance or significant personal assets, it is often advisable to research the possibility of reaching a settlement with a structured payment plan. Basically, the parties agree on a certain settlement amount. Instead of paying this amount as a lump sum, the "at- fault" party or its insurance company will purchase an appropriate "annuity" insurance plan from another insurance company that sells these special annuity plans. The injured victim will then receive guaranteed payments on a monthly, or annual basis. The plan may provide for a combination of lump sum payments periodically along with monthly or annual payments. These are normally guaranteed for a number of years but available for the life of the victim. For example, the plan may be guaranteed for twenty (20) years with payments for life. If the person lives longer than twenty (20) years, the plan will continue to pay for the remainder of the victim's life. If the person dies before twenty (20) years, the balance of the payments through the twentieth year are paid to a designated beneficiary. No payments are made past the twentieth year.

There are several advantages to a structured settlement. First, the annuity payments are not taxable. If the injured victim was to receive a lump sum settlement, and invested that money, the interest income on the investment is taxable. In a structured settlement, the insurance company in effect invests the money for the benefit of the victim and the annuity payments are considered part of the personal injury settlement which is not taxable. Second, this is a means of insuring that the money will be there as needed. All too often people mismanage large amounts of money and fall prey to hustlers and con artists who will take advantage of them. By placing the proceeds of a personal injury settlement in a structure, the injured victim may be better protected from mistakes or abuse. Finally, the insurance companies are sometimes more interested in offering a structure which may yield a valuable annuity, but which they may purchase at a discounted amount. This allows the insurance company to save on the settlement cost, but does not devalue what the injured victim receives in benefits.

The ability to enter into a structured settlement largely depends on the availability of insurance and usually involves settlements of several hundred thousand to millions of dollars.

MEDICARE /MEDICAID, VETERANS ADMINISTRATION , AND OTHER GOVERNMENT BENEFITS

The injured TBI or SCI victim may be entitled to receive certain government benefits if they qualify. Medicaid is a Federal system created to provide medical assistance to people who are in a defined financial category where they cannot afford the cost of care for themselves. It is generally available to persons over 65 and sometimes to persons under 65 who meet certain qualifications, such as persons under 65 who are receiving Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits.

The Medicaid program is a federal program administered by participating states. Both the federal government and the participating state governments contribute to the fund. Medicaid is a major provider of long term nursing care.

To qualify for Medicaid benefits is a bit complicated. It depends on whether the injured victim is married; widowed and receiving a pension and/or social security: or is single. What a person owns in assets can affect his or her ability to qualify. If a person attempts to transfer their assets in order to qualify, that can affect the timing of government paid benefits.

The TBI or SCI victim should contact the closest federal Social Security office to consult with a qualified representative to determine their eligibility for Medicaid benefits.

If the TBI or SCI victim is a veteran, he or she may be entitled to lifetime medical care and other benefits through the Veterans Administration even where the injury is not service related.

There are numerous other government resources provided by various states that may provide assistance to the TBI or SCI victim that should be explored. For example, if the injury was caused by someone who committed a crime, by a drunk driver perhaps, some states have a Crime Victims Fund that offers some financial assistance. If the injury was caused to a minor, there may be a program through the state or county Department of Social Services for Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC). In addition, there are numerous foundations and non-profit organizations which may offer financial assistance.

HEALTH INSURANCE AND HEALTH MAINTENANCE ORGANIZATION (HMO) COVERAGE

Even though the injuries may have been caused as the result of an accident where someone else is at fault, the injured victim's health insurance and/or HMO has an obligation to provide the medical care available under their coverage. Usually, it will take some time to sort out what insurance, if any, the person who caused the accident has and will pay. In the meantime, the injured victim needs immediate care. The victim's health carrier must cover that care. The health insurance company or HMO will usually then have the right to seek reimbursement from the "at-fault" party. This is called subrogation. The health insurance carrier or HMO may elect to claim a lien against any proceeds the injured victim they insure receives from a third party instead of pursuing their subrogation claim. This is referred to as a "third party lien" right.

The injured victim should always advise their health insurance carrier or their HMO immediately following any accident.

If you have any questions, one of our lawyers will be please to take the time to talk with you. Phone: (800) 617-2622 or email: mz@zalkin.com

 
Brain and Spine
Injury Attorneys



San Diego Office
12555 High Bluff Dr.
Suite 215
San Diego, CA 92130

New York Office
158 E. 35th St.
New York, NY 10016

Call Toll Free:
(800) 617-2622


Visit Our Website:

www.zalkin.com

Contact Us:
email

TOP OF PAGE